Rating scheme

[Bj]

I saw an interesting discussion over this topic on someone's sig, querying why the mods' views were the be-all and end-all.

They both made good points. I think you could open up reviewing a piece of work to everyone who wants to do so, and the mark /10 could be optional. But of the Mods or whichever governing body reviewed it, their views woud be highlighted in some way, because I would expect them to know what they're talking about, especially as they have gone to so much to make this website....

Which rocks.

[Kain]

Thx for bring that subject over here so we can try n keep on topic..

As i said in the other thread, I think a review board is a good idea because people want to know what others think of their work... I dont mind who gives the reviews because obviously different people will have different opinions and so any1 is allowed to give a review if they want.
However i do ask that it is done in a certain format.. as i said before: "5/10 needs work" is no good to anybody.. ur jus wasting ur time.. Ive been told that the reviews and feedback i give is helpful and so if we could keep reviews in the same format then it would be easier:

Good points:

1-
2-

Improvement areas:

1-
2-

Other comments:

couple more things i wanna add.. If u want to give a review and your thoughts are exactly the same as what some1 else has said, dont bother typing it all out again.. just say that u agree with whoever and add any other comments u would like to make.

last thing.. im sorry Chamy but id like to remove the X/10 rating system.

[Bj]

That seems reasonable - you could always alternatively get everyone to mark /10, and then averaged it

[CHaMY]

just delete the whole forum, just post about their sigs in the showoff?

[Kain]

can do if u want.. but a lot of people post more than one sig in showoff n so they arent likely to get specific feedback on certain sigs.. but ill leave that 1 up to u