Post by CHaMY on Feb 15, 2008 18:35:45 GMT -5
Welcome
Ok welcome to the review forum, this is where u can get some kind of idea of where you are in sig making terms.
OK! 1st things first... This review forum is not done on personal preference. Artwork is reviewed based on the skill used and overall outcome of the piece. This can be based around many aspects of the principles of a good piece of graphical work or specifically signature making.
If you have a dispute with a review, please remember, this review is not the be all and end all of the sig, remember that the staff are only trying to help you to improve and giving an honest opinion.
Guidlines For A Review
Ok, the reviews are given a rating out of 10. 10 being a perfect signature in all aspects and 1 being a poor signature with little skill used to create it. I very much doubt there will be many 1's or 10's to be honest. Here is the criteria:
1 - An extremely poor signature. Little skill used and very basic design.
2 - A weak signature. Little skill still used but improved outcome of that of a 1 rating.
3 - A weak signature. Slightly more skill used and many aspects of sig making taken into mind when making the tag.
4 - A below average signature. Principles taken into mind but put into little effect. Better outcome than a tag with rating of 3.
5 - An average signature. All round average with slightly better spec than that of a 4 rating.
6 - An above average signature. Good use of principles of artwork and a good outcome.
7 - A good signature. Advanced signature creating techniques starting to be used and outcomes is very good.
8 - An excellent signature. Great use of all techniques and very effective outcome.
9 - An outstanding piece of work. Indepth work and all principles applied excellently.
10 - Godly perfection. No more need to be said.
This is an outline made by me and is what all artists will be using when writing a review. This will be posted at the end of each review to remind you of where you are in you progression of sig making.
Review Outline
The following is the basic review that the artists will be using to review and rate your sig. giving you advice as they go to help you improve you skills further.
Signature image and who made it
Basic overview of the sig and opinion of it, hints
Positives
Negatives
(Both referring to principles of sig making e.g depth, colouring, lighting etc...)
How to improve
Rating
(e.g. 6/10 - An above average signature. Good use of principles of artwork and a good outcome.)
Remember that we are here to help, i hope this secion will be of great help to people, beginners, and experts
Ok welcome to the review forum, this is where u can get some kind of idea of where you are in sig making terms.
OK! 1st things first... This review forum is not done on personal preference. Artwork is reviewed based on the skill used and overall outcome of the piece. This can be based around many aspects of the principles of a good piece of graphical work or specifically signature making.
If you have a dispute with a review, please remember, this review is not the be all and end all of the sig, remember that the staff are only trying to help you to improve and giving an honest opinion.
Guidlines For A Review
Ok, the reviews are given a rating out of 10. 10 being a perfect signature in all aspects and 1 being a poor signature with little skill used to create it. I very much doubt there will be many 1's or 10's to be honest. Here is the criteria:
1 - An extremely poor signature. Little skill used and very basic design.
2 - A weak signature. Little skill still used but improved outcome of that of a 1 rating.
3 - A weak signature. Slightly more skill used and many aspects of sig making taken into mind when making the tag.
4 - A below average signature. Principles taken into mind but put into little effect. Better outcome than a tag with rating of 3.
5 - An average signature. All round average with slightly better spec than that of a 4 rating.
6 - An above average signature. Good use of principles of artwork and a good outcome.
7 - A good signature. Advanced signature creating techniques starting to be used and outcomes is very good.
8 - An excellent signature. Great use of all techniques and very effective outcome.
9 - An outstanding piece of work. Indepth work and all principles applied excellently.
10 - Godly perfection. No more need to be said.
This is an outline made by me and is what all artists will be using when writing a review. This will be posted at the end of each review to remind you of where you are in you progression of sig making.
Review Outline
The following is the basic review that the artists will be using to review and rate your sig. giving you advice as they go to help you improve you skills further.
Signature image and who made it
Basic overview of the sig and opinion of it, hints
Positives
Negatives
(Both referring to principles of sig making e.g depth, colouring, lighting etc...)
How to improve
Rating
(e.g. 6/10 - An above average signature. Good use of principles of artwork and a good outcome.)
Remember that we are here to help, i hope this secion will be of great help to people, beginners, and experts